1. Informed Consent: Parents for Justice set about highlighting
these issues. The group endeavoured to make the
concept of informed consent a working reality within
post-mortem practice.
The group acknowledges the difficulty inherent
in approaching a newly bereaved family/individual
and broaching the topic of organ removal/retention/disposal.
To this end, the group has been advocating that
a designated Bereavement Officer would be appointed
in all major hospitals where death is a sad but
frequent occurrence. The role of such an official
would be to act as an intermediary between health
professionals and the family.
Ideally he/she would help to span the bridge
that often exists between the medical and lay-person
's perspective of death. He/she would be instrumental
in developing and implementing a policy of informed
consent in the whole area of post-mortem practice.
Parents for Justice formalised this recommendation
in lengthy submissions to The Coroner 's Review
Group and to the Eastern Regional Health Authority.
The group welcomed the ERHA 's decision to appoint
such a designated post-mortem co-ordinator.
2. Information: The committee members have visited many hospitals
throughout the country since the beginning of
2000.We have expressed the degree of pain that
has been caused by post-mortem practices of the
past. We have emphasised the absolute necessity
for informed consent and information to underpin
all features of autopsy practice.
In response to the concerns expressed by the
group, most major hospitals have now introduced
comprehensive information leaflets about post-mortems.
Consent forms have been reviewed, updated or (in
some cases)introduced in the majority of Irish
hospitals. Parents for Justice has had significant
input n the drafting of these information leaflets
and consent forms. We have attempted to address
the issues which caused deepest hurt to our members
and to ensure that they never happen again.
3. Dignified Disposal: In direct response to the sense of outrage
most members experienced upon discovering the
methods of organ disposal which were in place
in Irish hospitals, most hospitals have by now
purchased a designated plot within a cemetery.
Organs are now interred n this plot, with the
consent of next-of-kin when all clinical/research
work has been completed. Alternatively, families
also have the option of reclaiming these organs
and arranging to have them buried in the family
plot.
The above are some of the visible and tangible
ways in which Parents for Justice have safeguarded
the rights of parents and next-of-kin and contributed
to their empowerment at a time when they are at
their most vulnerable.
4. Public Inquiry: Following an intensive lobbying campaign on
9th February 2000,the Minister for Health, Mr.Micheal
Martin TD, announced the establishment of a State
Inquiry into Post-Mortem policy practice and procedure
within the state since 1970.The Inquiry chaired
by Ms. Anne Dunne SC began its work on 5th March
2001.The valuable work of the Dunne Inquiry is ongoing.
Parents for Justice have afforded their co-operation
to this inquiry in the hope that it will provide
answers to the many legitimate and troubling questions
that surround past post-mortem practice. It is also
the hope of this group that the Chairperson 's report
will make recommendations which will ensure that
past practices will not be repeated and that current/future
practices will be in line with best international
practice.
5. Human Tissue Legislation: The group has vigorously campaigned for a Human
Tissue Act which would regulate by statute the practice
of pathology within the state. The Minister for
Health Mr. Micheal Martin TD has repeatedly assured
the group that this legislation will be introduced
and that Parents for Justice or its nominees, will
have a consultative role n the drafting of this
legislation.
Parents for Justice would envisage that a Human
Tissue Act would copper-fasten the rights of next-of-kin
to explicit informed consent about post-mortem
practice. We would also hope that such an Act
would provide a statutory framework within which
the practice of pathology would be regulated in
a way that would safeguard and ensure pathologists
/ research workers, continued access to human
organs/tissue for the continuation and advancement
of their very valuable work.
It remains our belief that had consent for the
retention of organs for research /education projects
been sympathetically and truthfully sought, that
parents and next-of-kin would have responded to
such requests with generosity. A Human Tissue
Act, we would hope, would enshrine the rights
of next-of-kin while safeguarding and endorsing
the work of pathologists, consultants and researchers.
6. To clarify confusion
between organ retention and voluntary donation:
Parents for Justice has been saddened by the
willingness of some to attribute the fall-off in
voluntary organ donation to the campaigning work
of this group. There has been undeniably, a reduction
in the number of organs being made available for
transplant programmes.
Parents for Justice in conjunction with the Irish
Kidney Association has continuously pointed to
the need for education about the difference between
organ retention and organ donation. The group
has publicly supported the work of the Irish Kidney
Association and has also written to the Transplant
Co-ordinators in all of the major hospitals offering
our support in whatever way possible to resolve
this unsatisfactory situation.
Further Objectives
A lot has been achieved in
a relatively short time. However there is still
much to do. Parents for Justice is committed to
ensuring that Ms. Dunnes report on Post-Mortem
policy practice and procedure within this state
will not become another forgotten tomb collecting
dust in some remote archive.
We will continue to lobby the government of the
day to ensure that sufficient funding is made
available to implement the recommendations of
this report and also those of the Coroners
Review Report. The recommendations will not be
allowed to remain simply worthy aspirations, they
will become working realities in every hospital
and health board area in this country. We are
committed to fostering a collaborative relationship
with hospitals and health professionals. It is
only through dialogue and mutual respect, that
we can all move forward.
The healthcare system faces many challenges in
the years ahead. Parents for Justice looks forward
to playing an integral part in the radical reform
that is already under way.
Parents for Justice Limited
Kantoher Business Park, Kantoher, Ballagh, Co. Limerick.
Breda Butler Cork 086 103 7490 - Charlotte Yeates Dublin 087 624 7327
Email: info@parentsforjustice.com